For some odd reason, I feel the need to repost this. Originally posted 9/4/08.
Also known as…. how pirating/filesharing sites cost readers in general.

more animals
Today I had plans to get some work done on a Hunter novella I’m planning on submitting to EC-that was my morning task.
My afternoon task won’t change-I’m working on my third book in my current Berkley contract and putting together a proposal for three more books. Deadlined type of stuff, which takes priority and can’t wait.
Plans fell apart and instead of spending a few hours working on a new ebook for EC, I spent several hours–yes, hours, not a few minutes, but half of my morning, dealing with a few sites that have my pirated work loaded onto them. I watch the sites on a regular basis. On a regular basis, I have to take time away from writing to deal with these sites.
Which means I’m taking time away from writing more ebooks. As I said, the stuff for Berkley is already contracted, under deadline, it doesn’t wait. I’m not using family time to deal with piracy, either. Being a mom is priority #1.
So where do I have to sacrifice to deal with this? By not working on an ebook. Which means…it takes longer to get one written, which means…I don’t write as many. I don’t put out as many books.
This is beyond frustrating for me. I realize it’s not exactly fair to those who don’t fileshare/pirate.
But I have little choice. I have to protect my work-there’s no question of not doing that. Not for me. If I don’t stand up for my rights as a writer, nobody will. So I have to do this.
I have to meet my deadlines, because if I don’t, I won’t have as good a chance at getting more contracts. I do need the income I get from writing ebooks still…
Or rather, I need some supplementary income-however, it’s becoming glaringly clear that I don’t have to get that supplementary income from writing. Especially when it’s becoming less and less worth it on a financial level, considering the time I put into my books.
I’m a trained professional. I’m in a career where there is high demand. Sadly, something I’m considering more and more is to stop writing ebooks altogether and pick up a part time job in nursing. Working parttime, I can still meet my deadlines for Berkley, and since nurses tend to have a lot of flexible options when it comes to shift work, I can pick up a few shifts that won’t cut into weekends too much.
However, if I decide to go that route, that means I may end up not writing any more books for ebook publication. I’m done with staying up until 2 or 3 in the morning to try and get a book done, yet get up to go into work @ six. If I go back to work part time, my writing time is going to devoted to my books that I sell to NYC.
Most of the people reading this probably understand/respect the fact that I have a right to protect my work. I have the right to benefit from those works-it is my job. But I know some people think that writers do it just to have their work read and the gratification/benefits should come regardless of how people read the work. These people are wrong.
For a writer, the gratification comes from knowing that you’re able to put your talents to use in a way that lets you provide for your family.
My writing is my income. My income is what lets me provide for my family. Knowing that I’m doing that is my gratification. Doesn’t mean I don’t love writing books that people enjoy reading. But the ultimate gratification comes from when I can give my kids more than I had as a child. It comes from knowing that I’ll be able to provide for them, care for them, give them all the little extras I wish I’d had as a child.
That’s my gratification. If I’m not able to do that, then busting my tail keeping up a steady stream of ebooks as well as my NY releases isn’t rewarding. It’s demoralizing. It’s depressing. If I don’t find the benefits in writing for multiple houses and writing my tail off, well, then I’ll stop the ebooks, get a part time job and focus more on the NY releases.
Yes, I know those get pirated, but I also know their legal departments are more capable of handling these messes, quicker and more thorough. I also know I make better money writing for NY and as I get more established, that will only improve. My stability with NY is becoming more and more solid with every passing month. My stability with my ebook pubs decreases…more and more every each month.
Whether people read my books or not, if they like reading, then they are affected by filesharing and pirating. Many authors try to be vigilant and protect their work-which means…they take time away from writing. Which means…fewer books. I’m a reader, too. I know what I want is MORE books from my faves, not fewer.
So yes, filesharing and pirating hurts readers, too.
Man, talk about a depressing way to start the day.
Added 12/15/08~ Please…don’t bother wasting your time arguing how piracy doesn’t really hurt authors and how some people go onto buy the books after they illegally download them. You’re not the one who put hours upon hours into a book only to have people take it without paying for it. It would be kind of like you working a 60+ work week, expecting some time and a half on your pay check but when you open that sucker up, it’s more like a 40 work week at minimum wage, instead of the $20+/hour you were expecting-and NONE of the time and a half. You wouldn’t like it, and guess what, neither do I. You’re thinking…but that’s illegal, my work can’t do that. Pirating is also illegal-even the FBI says so.
“Warning: The unauthorized reproduction or distribution of this copyrighted work is illegal. Criminal copyright infringement, including infringement without monetary gain, is investigated by the FBI and is punishable by up to 5 years in federal prison and a fine of $250,000.”
So unless you can sit there and tell me honestly you wouldn’t care if people were depriving you of money you rightly earned, don’t tell me I shouldn’t care, I shouldn’t worry, or that I’m being ‘a pain’. It’s my work-I’m entitled to receive compensation for the time I put into it.
Don’t hand me some line how I should be grateful that people just want to read me. I can’t feed my kids, provide for my family on ‘gratitude’ and I don’t write just so people will read me. That’s a bunch of poetic nonsense. I write because it’s my job and it’s one I’m good at.
Whatever excuses pirates use to justify (when they bother) are just more crap.
I spend hours protecting my work, hours that should be devoted to writing MORE books, but since pirates don’t care and continue to pirate, I keep having to spend those hours protecting work.
So today, yet again, instead of working on an ebook, I did several hours dealing with piracy crap and the rest of the afternoon was focused on a book that won’t be out until 2011. Because I have to protect my work, I spend less time writing and more time dealing with the hassles, which means…fewer books.
Something tells me that my legit readers won’t like that, so to all the pirates out there who think piracy hurts nobody…guess what…you’re wrong. You’re robbing from the readers who actually care enough to buy, and ironically, even from yourself.
Even if you don’t read my books, you’ve got fave authors and many, many, many authors also spend a great deal of time fighting piracy. From the epubbed right on up to those on the bestseller lists.
The next time you download and finish a book and wonder, man, when’s the next one coming out…think about the fact that if the author wasn’t spending so much time on other stuff, like dealing with pirates, the book you want could have already been written.
December 16, 2008 at 12:59 am
Dude, I’m sorry. That sucks royally.
(What sites do you check?)
December 16, 2008 at 1:23 am
Ann, more than I care to list. For a variety of reasons.
December 16, 2008 at 2:09 pm
Shiloh:
I am so sorry this happens to you. For myself, I am so worried about this happening if I take my computer in for work I take all the files off and load them back after I get the computer back.
Hang in there.
December 16, 2008 at 3:17 pm
Geez, and PBW just had this problem too. What is wrong with people? It’s common sense to me that you just don’t DO that. I have to say though, people who bother defending it get me more than the actual act. I can expect some immoral clods to DO it, but for people to try to rationalize it? Ew. I’m so sorry, Shiloh.
December 16, 2008 at 7:17 pm
This is awful! I’m not a huge ebook reader myself, but I make sure to purchase the book before reading it. I could ask a friend to email me a copy, and justify it as “borrowing” the book like I do with print books, but that goes into such a grey area that I’m avoiding it. If I don’t buy, I don’t read. End of story. It sucks that people don’t get the copyright issues and feel they can do whatever they want. If more people put themselves in the shoes of the author, this may slow down if not stop. Ugh.
December 16, 2008 at 8:15 pm
Shiloh, I’m sorry to hear how badly this has affected you. I had never really thought about it or realized how widespread it is. You definitely have a right to protect your work and I’m saddened that you have to take so much time to do so. I will be sad if you are forced to stop working on ebooks because of this, but I understand why.
December 16, 2008 at 9:36 pm
Thanks for the support, guys. It means a lot.
Yeah, I know PBW blogged about it, too. A whole bunch of us are getting hit lately, and bad.
Piracy costs publishing so much money every year. The pirates ‘claim’ well, i wouldn’t have bought the book anyway, so it doesn’t cost them MY money…
But that’s flawed logic. When they buy the book, they basically pay for the right to read it. If they don’t want to buy it, check it out from the library. Do something that doesn’t hurt copyright and cost pubs, and authors, money.
Plus, there are actually a lot of people reading bootlegged copies who don’t realize it’s illegal and that it is such a huge problem. If it’s costing pubs billions, that means it’s trickling down to authors and costing us, too. A decent number of people like to do the right thing, the moral thing.
Flat out, I think pirates are immoral and I don’t care if they approve of my views or not. They aren’t the ones being hurt by this.
But they are so blase about it, excuse it away, act like they aren’t doing anything wrong, even though they KNOW they are-and they have others thinking there’s nothing wrong with it.
They don’t tell people who illegally and unknowingly download the files, By reading this, you’re breaking the law, violating copyright and hurting the author’s income. If more decent people knew, there would be a lot less of it going on.
Sigh. Depressing. Very, very. I think for the next few weeks, I’m just going to focus on the stuff for Berkley and Ballantine, make some headway on my deadlines there and let my mind chill about the piracy crap. Yeah, yeah, I know the big pubs/traditonal pubs get it, too. But I saw a few of my print titles listed…as opposed to HUNDREDS of my ebook titles.
When I’m a little less depressed about the ebooks, I’ll focus on the current one again.
December 16, 2008 at 9:43 pm
Shiloh, I’m sorry to hear about the time you have to waste to monitor these sites that are pirating your books. I hate the thought of you and other author’s having to go through this and maybe stop writing ebooks. For Mother’s Day I got a Sony eReader and though I still buy more hard copy books than ebooks, I am enjoying the convenience of my eReader. I buy my ebooks either from the Sony eStore or directly from the publisher (Avon, EC, Samhain, Kensington, etc.). And I don’t share any of the ebooks I have bought, they are kept on my eReader and backed up on a removable USB drive.
You definitely have the right to protect your work from being stolen and the right to receive compensation for your work. I understand completely your reasons for not wanting to waste your valuable time dealing with the illegal sites. As a fellow nurse I know that there is a demand for nurses though I would hate for you to have to work, even parttime, in a field that is so physically and mentally draining that takes you away, even a little, from your writing.
December 16, 2008 at 10:30 pm
Hugs, Shi–may those pirates’ hard drives crash in horrible, unrecoverable ways. Grr!
December 17, 2008 at 2:50 am
Kathygp, yeah, it would kinda suck, but I’m a good nurse. If I gotta do it, I gotta do it. At least I have options.
Fedora…*G* I’m a big believer in ‘reap what you sow’. Or call it karma. You do negative crap, sooner or later, it catches up with you. It will catch up with them if it hasn’t already.
The real beauty will be if any of them are aspiring authors.
December 20, 2008 at 11:07 pm
This is just awful! I read/review for JERR and you are one of my favorite authors. I prefer eBooks because they cost less and I can read them on my eBookwise. I will buy paperbacks-depending on the author-I recently bought “The Missing” and loved it! Does this mean that you are going to cut back on the ebooks that you write? HORRID!
December 20, 2008 at 11:43 pm
Marcy, it’s already cut back on the amount of ebooks I write. I’ve been steadily cutting back for the past year and some projects that were originally slated for my epubs have been put on the side.
Single titles, unrelated to other series, but these are books that are going to be time-consuming. Time consuming but not quite right for my New York publishers, so they are just pushed to the side until I decide what to do with them.
But Mythe is the first series I’ve completely tabled over this. I honestly can’t say it’s the last, though. If a ebook is going to take more time than I can justify spending on it, then it won’t be sent to my epubs.
December 21, 2008 at 1:05 am
I’m sorry I love the books because they take up alot of room but you should be able to make money them
December 22, 2008 at 6:06 pm
It’s kind of sad that people have to be reminded of this, Shiloh.
Writing is hard work, and authors deserve to get properly paid for that hard work. I’ll be sorry to miss out on many new ebooks from you, but I absolutely understand that you have to look out for yourself and your family’s best interests.
January 6, 2009 at 12:56 pm
[...] Shiloh Walker says piracy hurts the readers too. She’s also halting all writing in the middle of a series. How sa… [...]
January 7, 2009 at 12:14 pm
[...] How Piracy Also Affects Readers: shilohwalker.wordpress.com/2008/12/16/how-piracy-also-affects-readers/ [...]
January 8, 2009 at 5:31 pm
There should be a program incorporated into e-books that if the book is transferred from the original downloaded e-reader, or computer, that the book becomes scrambled. If we can send men to the moon, we should be able to stop e-book “sharing”.
January 8, 2009 at 6:54 pm
I wouldn’t necessarily say from reader to computer, because I store my ebooks on my PC and my laptop, then transfer to my Sony.
I’d say more like if it gets ‘passed’ more than x amount of times, it gets scrambled…or self destructs…
January 8, 2009 at 10:25 pm
My God! That’s it! Can a computer or an e-book be coded to one certain computer and e-book reader in ONE name? That’s the secret! An E-book can only move around in the buyers named computer and their readers, This could work! .
January 9, 2009 at 2:23 am
Assuming somebody would do it. Although, still, we’d have to deal with the people who hack and break the code just for the hell of it. This ‘everything’ should be shared crap.
Of course, if they want to share their income with me to help offset the fact that they are affecting my job, hey, then we can talk. *Rolling eyes*
May 25, 2009 at 3:57 pm
I agree, it is a shame people get their ebooks illegally. It hurts everyone. I buy a lot of ebooks. I mean a lot. One day I get this email from someone and she sends me lists and lists of ebooks and wants me to purchase them for $2 thru paypal. I would like to know how she knew I purchase ebooks. She said she knew I purchased a lot. How? I never told anyone at that time I had purchased. Can people who work for ebook companies be doing this? Makes you wonder. She had some of yours on these lists. I acted like I was interested trying to find out more info. Never could figure it out. I had to up security and be more careful on my accounts. So sad……
May 25, 2009 at 4:00 pm
I forgot to mention ebay ebooks. Aren’t they illegal to sell on ebay? There are some in fiction paranormal by this well known popular author that are always for sale. They sell all the time. These people are raking in the money. I turn their sites in over and over and tried to contact the author but could not get her email or anyway to contact. Wish I could have helped more. I love to read series and is so frustrating to wait but totally understand why we have to wait for books. Please keep up the good work, there are many many of us that appreciate the books. It keeps me going day after day when that is all I can do.
May 26, 2009 at 7:49 am
Hi Sandra
Yep, reselling ebooks is illegal. Only authorized sites can sell them.
If you still have the lady’s email address, feel free to direct her to this post.
Because of piracy, I’ve gone from 8-10 ebooks a year to 4-5. This year, I believe I had 5 out (not including my New York titles. Next year, I’ll between 3-5 ebooks out. Writing less, fewer ebooks. Do readers really want the authors they enjoy making choices like this? Sigh….