Ebook Piracy

I debated a long time about whether or not to discuss this and in the end, it seems I’m having a hard time not saying anything.

For those that don’t do ebook file sharing/pirating, you have no idea how grateful I, and other epubbed authors, are to you.

For those that do it, know it’s wrong and don’t care, well, you don’t need to read any further. You aren’t the ones I’m addressing.

This post is for those that either don’t realize it’s illegal, or those that realize it is, but they don’t realize it hurts authors.

Pirated ebooks infringe on my copyright. Filesharing sites infringe on my copyright. But it isn’t just that it’s illegal, it’s a practice that hurts authors. People who might have gone and bought those ebooks but then turn around and buy a batch for $20 or just use a sharing site, all of these adds up to less income for the writer.

Why should that matter to the reader? I mean, money is tight for everybody and if the reader can save a few bucks either filesharing or buying pirated ebooks, does it really hurt?

Yes. If you like that author, do you want them to keep writing and putting out more ebooks for you? Ebook publishing has some pros to it that you don’t find in print publishing~ quick release times, more frequent releases, shorter word length counts.

For those of us that write quick, doing both ebook and print makes sense….provided it’s worth it to the writer. I can write at my normal pace, keep up a steady flow of releases, keep my income steady. But when I see ebooks being illegally sold, keeping me from earning my rightful royalties, it makes me wonder if perhaps I shouldn’t focus more on the print side of my career. This is an issue I’ve discussed with fellow writers and I know I’m not the only one making career decisions and piracy has been a deciding factor for some.

I want to make it clear, I’m not trying to be greedy. I just want people to stop sharing my ebooks. I’m entitled to my rightful royalties on those ebooks. Writers are people just like anybody else, and we have the same expenses as anybody else. Our writing is what lets us pay those expenses.

I don’t want anybody thinking that I feel they are responsible for my income. They aren’t. I am. But when I write a book and publish it, it’s with the belief that I’m going to get compensated. That’s why I quit the day job. So I could write full time and make a living from it. Writing is my job. It’s how I provide for my kids. It’s how I pay my bills. It’s how I buy my own books, clothes, movies, etc, etc… this is my paycheck.

Speaking for me, my career is coming to a crossroads. A definitive decision now isn’t necessary, but that time is coming. I love romance. I love writing it. I plan to continue writing it. But there are other genres I want to explore. A deciding factor is going to be what happens over the next year with my epubs and if it looks like writing for my epubs isn’t as the wisest choice, then as much as I’d hate it, I’m going to move on.

I rarely ask anything from anybody. It’s just not in me. But those of you reading this that weren’t aware it was a legal thing, and more, one that has a negative impact on authors, I’d like you to consider all of this. For those are aware that filesharing & ebook piracy is wrong, but they don’t think it hurts anybody, I’m asking you to reconsider that viewpoint. It does hurt people-it hurts the authors and it hurts them in a place none of us like being hurt, right square in the wallet.

If anybody has questions about the legality of pirating ebooks, there is some info on it below. But if legel-eze bores you, I understand. It’s not all that fascinating for me either.

From USINFO.STATE.GOV

Focus on Intellectual Property Rights by Thomas G. Field, Jr

Why do countries such as the United States, Japan, and The Netherlands protect inventions; literary and artistic works…They do so because they know safeguarding these property rights fosters economic growth, provides incentives for technological innovation, and attracts investment that will create new jobs and opportunities for all their citizens.

If you’re still questioning on whether this really is a crime…anything copyrighted is protected under federal law. The cybercrime.gov site lists copyright piracy on their site.

From Copyright Basics @ Copyright, the US Copyright Office.

What Is Copyright

Copyright is a form of protection provided by the laws of the United States (title 17, U. S. Code) to the authors of “original works of authorship,” including literary, dramatic, musical, artistic, and certain other intellectual works. This protection is available to both published and unpublished works.

Violating copyright is illegal. From the FAQs section at Copyright.gov

Section 501 of the copyright law states that “anyone who violates any of the exclusive rights of the copyright owner …is an infringer of the copyright or right of the author.”

Writing is hard work. Every author I’ve ever known has worked hard to get published. It’s our creation… our intellectual property and we deserve to have that copyrighted work respected.

19 Responses to “Ebook Piracy”

  1. You are the third author who has posted about it this month. It makes me so very angry that people don’t get it–not just that it’s wrong, which is a big, huge, humongous DUH!!! but also that they are shooting themselves in the foot.

    Writers can’t spend time writing if they have to wait tables / clean houses / answer phones / do research / take your pick in order to pay the bills.

    I am sorry it has touched you too, Shiloh.

  2. Aztec, chances are, if the epubbed author has books out at even a moderately well-known epub, they are going to have titles pirated at some point.

    It’s an issue I’m aware of and usually, I just try to ignore it, but it’s not always the easiest thing. Since I kept stewing over it, I figured I at least needed to discuss. Getting upset over a problem and not even trying to address it is a waste of time.

    ;) At least now I’ve made the attempt, so I feel a little bit justified getting upset.

  3. I just don’t understand how someone could be such a dumbass (because there’s no other damn word for it) and illegally share ebooks which not only hurts the author but OTHERS readers as well.

  4. I just don’t understand how someone could be such a dumbass (because there’s no other damn word for it) and illegally share ebooks which not only hurts the author but OTHERS readers as well.

    Wendy, it boils down (probably) to them thinking either

    a) authors make so much money, they won’t miss it (LMAO~yeah, I wish)

    b) a few books here and there isn’t going to hurt.

    c) they don’t realize that the only way the author gets paid is if people actually BUY the ebook they are reading.

    d) they might honestly not realize that ebooks are copyrighted works and filesharing sites violate copyright/hurt authors/are illegal.

    If the books don’t sell enough to justify the expense put into it, then the author may not get new contracts. I’m established enough as an ebook author that I’m probably okay as far as contracts go.

    If they don’t get that it’s illegal and causes problems, both career-wise and financially for the author, then the only thing to do is educate them. Thus the reason for my post.

    But the other arguments? Eh, writers in general don’t make the sort of money people seem to think. So yes, every book does make a difference.

    Five people downloading five pirated books each, then the people who downloaded those five turn around and do the same, and the cycle keeps going, it can add up to huge losses for authors.

    Epublishing is a business. If the author isn’t making money for herself and for her publisher, future books can definitely be at risk.

  5. If the author isn’t making money for herself and for her publisher, future books can definitely be at risk.

    This is the part that should be repeated loudly and frequently in the hearing of those who lack moral compass (so they really can’t see what’s wrong with file sharing). Where the concepts of right and wrong fail, self interest may succeed.

    (Who are you calling cynic?)

  6. This is the part that should be repeated loudly and frequently in the hearing of those who lack moral compass (so they really can’t see what’s wrong with file sharing). Where the concepts of right and wrong fail, self interest may succeed.

    (Who are you calling cynic?)

    LOL. Yeah, there is that.

    Although I’m a hopeful pessimist and I like to think that maybe just a few who hadn’t realized this IS problem will take another look and next time decide to buy instead of just take.

    But if self-interest does it, I’m all for that.

  7. *sigh* file sharing seems to have become a much bigger problem in the last year or so, and it’s having an impact. Like you, I have to ask myself if I can afford to keep writing ebooks. Not that print books don’t get pirated, too, but at least you get an advance for those.

  8. I never even thought about pirating ebooks until I saw posts about it. Not that I would - especially considering it never even occurred to me- but it seems like I see a blog about it almost every day now.
    Just makes you wonder about people…

  9. This is an excellent post Shiloh. I am glad I dropped by (first time visiting).

    Your comment that people think authors ‘make so much money’ really rings true. Our society has a tendency to see anyone with their face on television or their name in print as a celebrity. We’ve been brainwashed into thinking that all celebrities are rich and live some kind of magical life. Ergo, its ok to steal from them because they won’t miss it.

    I had high hopes for the ebook industry because its such an effective use of technology (and I can get my hands on my books faster LOL) but if it represents a big loss for authors I am willing to let it go.

    keep on writing your great books!
    Laura

  10. I emailed a print author that somebody was pirating her books on a website and got one of those “thanks for emailing so-and-so, she loves hearing from her fans”–generic replies. Well, I am chunking out my hard earned dinero for her books and her total nonchalance about thievery just irked my soul.

    If she doesn’t care if she gets paid, why should I? And why should I be scrupulous and actually purchase her books?

    Maybe it was automated, but she came off like a dunce.

  11. Jackie L, you did a good deed. My agent has started to do periodic searches and will send out notices of illegal file-sharing to her clients, but the time and effort involved to do a take-down notice is still, well, one more thing on a very overloaded plate, LOL.

  12. What really ticks me off is the people who try to make it sound like they’re doing something noble by ‘liberating’ copyrighted material. That makes me see red. You really can’t reason with those folks. Particularly since when it comes down to it, it’s just plain ol’ justification for thievery.

    Do what you have to in order to feed yourself and your family, Shiloh. That’s what matters. You work hard on these books, and you earn every penny you should be getting.

  13. I consider myself pretty internet savvy and it never occurred to me to even search for pirated ebooks. Sometimes after reading a particularly awful ebook, I wish I could get my money back. But I just chalk it up to taking one for the team b/c there’s so many other ebooks that I took a chance on and liked. I think what it comes down to is that people who steal, whether it’s content or actual products, know it’s wrong. Asking them not to? Not sure it’s gonna make a difference.

    I am curious about what you said about trying other genres though? Which ones? Will the books still have romantic elements but not be romances? Or different entirely? Oh no! Makes me think of all those romance authors who now write murder mysteries…

  14. Do what you have to in order to feed yourself and your family, Shiloh.

    Oh, trust me… lol…. that’s not a problem. I’m just tired of people not getting the fact if these books were meant to be free… they would be.

    What really ticks me off is the people who try to make it sound like they’re doing something noble by ‘liberating’ copyrighted material.

    Noble. Snort. Okay, they wanna be noble, then they write a book (that’s all it takes for something to be copyrighted~writing it) and then they can let people choose between paying for it or giving it away.

    “thanks for emailing so-and-so, she loves hearing from her fans”–generic replies

    Jackie, I’d imagine it’s problem an auto reply, yeah probably would sound weird ‘oh, thank you, i love hearing from readers’ when you’re emailing about such a problem, but auto replies…eh, one of the reasons I rarely use them is because of things like this.

    Your comment that people think authors ‘make so much money’ really rings true. Our society has a tendency to see anyone with their face on television or their name in print as a celebrity.

    Laura, thanks for dropping by. :)

    ;) One question I get asked a lot by casual friends who know I’ve quit the day job to write is… so how is the BOOK going Book. As in singular.

    if a writer wants to make it as a writer, much less earning a living as a writer, there isn’t a BOOK. There are books, usually written on weekends, evenings, and lunch hour while working the day job.

    And for the lucky ones, maybe there will come a time when there is just writing books~as the job. But just one book?

    :| Uh…nope. Never just one.

    I never even thought about pirating ebooks until I saw posts about it. Not that I would -

    And I love ya for it.

    *sigh* file sharing seems to have become a much bigger problem in the last year or so, and it’s having an impact. Like you, I have to ask myself if I can afford to keep writing ebooks

    Right now, finances aren’t going to force the issue. I’m luckier than some, I think, and thank God regularly for it. But I’m tired busting my tail like this just to see so many things pirated. It’s rapidly approaching the NOT WORTH IT point.

  15. I am curious about what you said about trying other genres though? Which ones? Will the books still have romantic elements but not be romances? Or different entirely? Oh no! Makes me think of all those romance authors who now write murder mysteries…

    In all honestly, I can’t give a definite answer to that. Just because writers are constantly changing and evolving. If I had to hazard a guess, I’d say the majority of my stuff is always either going to be romance or something written with strong romantic elements. I don’t know if I could write something with absolutely NO romance/romantic elements.

    I consider myself pretty internet savvy and it never occurred to me to even search for pirated ebooks.

    To quote myself… we love you for it. You have no idea how much. :)

  16. I don’t honestly purchase many ebooks - there are just a handful of authors (hmm, who would that be?) that I will read in that format. Why? I am a tactile, paper feelin’ kinda girl. That being said - sharing, pirating, illegal down loads, black market gimmees - let’s say it like it is, this is out right bloody STEALING!! No two ways about it. You do it you are stealing. End of story.

    The truth is people that do share or download illegally, etc are not thinking about the author or the publishing laws or anything else, they are looking at what they get. I have a friend who does not buy any music or movies, it is all pirated and it doesn’t matter what I say she doesn’t get it.

    I know that I would feel just like you if I had my blood, sweat and tears out there in ebook form (or any form) and it was being stolen from me I would be more than pissed. Hmm, I think I am pissed, just thinking about it, for you and the gazillion other authors this happens to on a daily basis. Utter rubbish.

    The more attention this gets the more action will be seen - in what form (?) really just depends on who is involved.

    It sucks dude, sorry.

    Peace.

  17. OH, I forgot to add…you write it…I will read it…

    Peace.

  18. Hi, Shiloh,
    Great post, and I agree with everyone’s who’s said that pirating is stealing, horrible, and just plain wrong. I think that it’s likely that because it’s so easy and because this is the kind of crime where the perpetrator doesn’t see his/her victim, people are more inclined to do it. Those aren’t by any means justification because as we already agreed, it’s WRONG!
    I’m sorry that there are people who stomp all over your right to be properly compensated for your work, and ultimately do affect all of us readers when it affects whether it makes sense for you to continue providing e-books.

  19. I am A big Fan of you, man .. you ROCK ! :)

Leave a Reply